Supreme Court Judge Siraj Desai from Cape Town – Western Cape took less than five minutes to deny Henri Van Breda's request to refuse permission to challenge his conviction and conviction.
Desai led the process that stretched over a period of 66 days and condemned in May the 23-year-old of January's triple-ax murders of his parents and brother, the attempted murder of his sister and defeating the ends of justice.
He sentenced him to three life sentences, 145 years for attempted murder and a year for defeating the ends of justice, and ordered the sentences to run at the same time.
Last week, after hearing the arguments of the defense in their attempt to appeal, Judge Desai said that one rarely gets a case against a suspect who is as strong as this one.
"This suitcase fits like a mosaic, pieces of a puzzle … everything fits together."
After considering the arguments of lawyer Piet Botha, Desai remained adamant that there were no compelling reasons for appealing.
Desai said that the state had "convincingly" established that Van Breda was responsible for committing the crimes.
"The main pillars of the state's case are convincing evidence of its debt and are in fact untouchable."
He said that a lower sentence would not have been appropriate "in the light of the horrible nature of the crimes". Moreover, there was no other mitigating factor than youthfulness and a lack of previous beliefs.
"Hopefully this is the last word on the matter," he said.
But lawyer-lawyer Piet Botha confirmed to journalists that it will not be. Botha will submit a petition to the Supreme Court in Bloemfontein and submit file documents within 15 days. If the SCA refuses the application for leave to appeal, there is no other means left and Van Breda will have to accept his fate behind the bars.
Van Breda proclaimed his innocence during the trial and told the court that at least one, possibly two, invaders were behind the murders.
Judge Desai rejected his version when he condemned him in May and said it was "absurd" that intruders would have entered the parental home and fled without taking anything.
In his judgment, he described Van Breda as a "cold-blooded murderer" and said that the attacks on the family members were carried out with the intention of killing.
African news agency / ANA